Skip to content
Posted inNews

The ‘Sunnyside Swamp’ continues to plague Petrides baseball

Panthers are likely to turn into road warriors once again due to poor playing conditions, a situation which seems to be an annual event.

By Posted byStephen Hart

Published:
Some sort of homemade contraption sits atop a puddle located near third base on the Petrides baseball field, which was under water after a mild rainstorm on Thursday, May 16. The soaking relegated the Panthers to simply tossing the ball around the outfield on Friday following a postponement of the regular-season finale against CSI/McCown. That game will be made up on Saturday at New Springville Little League. With all these problems, the Panthers are still 9-4.

It’s not that the people at Petrides High School are angry at other schools that have gotten their baseball fields refurbished by the Department of Education and the PSAL.

Jealous? Maybe. Confused? Definitely.

“It’s not like we’re in Brooklyn; we’re lucky to have our own field,” said Anthony Hillery, the longtime Panthers head coach, who stepped down after last season with a 2017 PSAL city championship on his resume. “But if you look around, everyone [on Staten Island] has had their field done.

“What happened to us?”

While the rain this week wasn’t necessarily heavy, it still managed to turn the Panthers’ Sunnyside field into its usual quagmire. Two puddles filled the batters’ box; more water resided around both first and third base; and the worst of the mess was reserved for the area near shortstop, spreading into the shallow portion of the outfield.

A puddle sits around the shortstop area on Petrides’ field as the Panthers practice in the outfield on Friday, May 17.

“[Thursday] was the worst I’ve seen in a while,” said first-year head coach Joey Pena. “We spent almost the entire practice fixing the field.”

“We spent 40 minutes just working on the field,” confirmed sophomore shortstop Rocky Molinare, who couldn’t take grounders again on Friday, as the players were relegated to just tossing the ball around the deeper parts of the outfield.

“It’s very frustrating. I know it affects a lot of our infielders,” added junior catcher Lorenzo LaMattina. “Third and first base are destroyed, so you can’t take infield reps. The same with the home plate area.”

Trying to conduct batting practice is also a work of fiction. Still, with all these problems, Petrides owns a 9-4 PSAL AA division record entering Saturday’s rescheduled regular-season finale against CSI/McCown. The game was supposed to be in Sunnyside, but the unplayable conditions has moved it to New Springville LL.

The aforementioned frustration stems from the fact that the field has never received any major makeover – dating back to when the College of Staten Island began using it in 1978.

Two puddles occupy the batters’ box at Petrides.

“In 46 years, the field has never been done,” said Hillery. “Meanwhile, schools like Curtis, Tottenville and Port Richmond have had their fields done twice.”

While the adjacent football field has been renovated, the baseball diamond is still populated by mud, high grass and dandelions.

“We only have one custodian here for the entire campus,” shrugged Tony D’Alessandro, the Petrides JV coach and varsity assistant, who has been with the school’s baseball program since its inception in 1998.

Aside from directly affecting games, the Sunnyside swamp has also been a factor when it comes to players’ futures.

“It doesn’t put us in a good position,” said LaMattina. “Other schools get more work in. Our guys can’t progress, so 100 percent it affects us when it comes to possibly getting scholarships. For someone like Rocky, he might have to deal with a couple of bad hops at shortstop that could lead to some bad throws to first base. What if a college coach is watching? On a good field, that doesn’t happen.

“There are no bleachers or stands for college coaches to sit and watch us. I remember last year when a college coach came here and he had to stand behind the backstop … it must have been pretty miserable for him.”

The lack of seating has also meant that parents are often forced to watch their sons from their cars, situated on an asphalt road located on a hill beyond the right-fielder.

The first-base bag appears buried in the mud at Petrides on Friday, May 17.

And the unattractive facilities have influenced some promising ballplayers attending Petrides’ middle school to leave for better equipped programs at other high schools.

“I’d rather play away games at Curtis or [McKee/S.I.] Tech than play at home,” Molinare noted.

“Many of our middle school kids leave for Catholic high schools,” said D’Alessandro. “If we had a nicer campus, maybe more kids would stay.”

The situation has also cost Petrides financially.

“Some Island coaches run summer camps out of their school. I was always reluctant,” admitted Hillery. “Not only was I worried about kids getting hurt [because of the poor conditions], but because I didn’t want to draw attention to the field. I didn’t want to show it off.”

And when foul balls pop into the air and travel behind home plate, there’s no covering above the backstop to block them. Instead, the foul balls carry into the high weeds behind the field, where they are often lost forever.

“We’re hemorrhaging balls,” said Hillery, an eighth grade American History teacher at Petrides, who has been showing Pena the ropes this season. “We can’t do batting practice because of it. We’re worried about having enough balls to get us through the week.”

Dandelions — and not players — took to the infield at Petrides on Friday.

Hillery and D’Alessandro remember someone from the PSAL coming to look at the field, “but that was years ago, and we never heard anything after that,” said D’Alessandro, who also pointed out that Petrides’ football and lacrosse teams use the field for practices after baseball season has ended – further tearing up the surface.

The problem isn’t new. En route to winning the PSAL AA city championship at Yankee Stadium, poor conditions forced the Panthers had to play a first-round home playoff game against Port Richmond away from Petrides.

Unfortunately, it appears the Panthers will have to be the Road Warriors again in 2024.

Signs of raking — done by the Petrides players and coaches — are evident on the muddy diamond Friday.

Recent Articles

Walsh, Muhammad lift Msgr. Farrell to season-opening win over Rhode Island’s top-ranked team

Move up in ranks a double-edged sword for McKee/S.I. Tech football

A teacher, colleague and friend: Memories of George Kochman

Monsignor Farrell football honors longtime coach Gary Romeo during preseason practice

Festa’s journey continues with Texas

How to revitalize MLB’s All-Star Game

Mets release Staten Island’s Matt Festa prior to Wednesday’s loss

Subscribe

Subscribe Form